The Tesla Mannequin S has loved a virtually 10-year debut within the premium electrical sedan competitors, however the hole is beginning to shut. One newcomer is giving the Mannequin S a run for its cash, and it comes from a fellow startup. The 2022 Lucid Air is an all-electric luxurious sedan that may compete with the Mannequin S in some areas and surpass it in others.
So, which is the higher electrical luxurious flagship, Tesla or Lucid? Automotive specialists at Edmunds in contrast these two long-range electrical automobiles to search out out.
Vary and Charging
The Lucid Air’s largest declare to fame is its distinctive driving vary. The highest-of-the-line Dream Version boasts a bladder-busting 520-mile EPA vary on a single cost. Tesla’s most providing is 405 miles, which continues to be beneficiant however lags behind even the entry-level Lucid by 451 miles. In Edmunds’ real-world vary testing, a Lucid Air Dream Version vary mannequin traveled 505 miles out of its marketed 520 miles. In the meantime, a Tesla Mannequin S Plaid on elective 21-inch wheels coated 345 miles in the identical take a look at, effectively in need of its 348-mile EPA ranking.
The Air is considered one of solely a handful of EVs that may use the utmost 350-kW charge obtainable at some DC fast-charging stations. The Mannequin S expenses at a slower most charge of 250 kW. In our testing of the Lucid, we measured an influence consumption charge of 28.3 kWh per 100 miles, versus 32.1 kWh per 100 miles within the Mannequin S (a decrease kWh quantity is best). Extra vary, higher effectivity and sooner charging give the Lucid Air a straightforward win right here.
Each the Air and Mannequin S have sports activities car-like efficiency capabilities. Teslas are recognized for his or her seat-pinning acceleration, however the Mannequin S Plaid takes it a step additional. Edmonds recorded a 0-60 mph run of simply 2.3 seconds and a quarter-mile time of 9.4 seconds—a loopy quantity by any normal. The Lucid can also be relentlessly quick, although, sprinting to 60 mph in 2.8 seconds in Edmunds’ testing Air Dream Version vary mannequin.
The obtainable Air Dream Version efficiency mannequin is much more highly effective with 1,111 horsepower on faucet and 21-inch wheels wrapped in summer time tires. These grippier tires are vital if you’d like a responsive and agile sedan as a result of with out them the dealing with of the air isn’t affected. The place the Mannequin S gives superior dealing with out of the field, each the sedans ship mind-blowing energy, interval. Simply cannot be the loser on this class.
inside and tech
Tesla has at all times been one of many danger takers and the Mannequin S Plaid’s controversial steering yoke is maybe its largest gamble. However you even have the corporate’s resolution to take away the normal column stalks and change them with touch-sensitive buttons, making easy instructions extra distracting whereas driving.
Lucid additionally has vital flaws on this space. Since Edmunds bought the 2022 Air Grand Touring for a one-year analysis, staff have highlighted the generally painfully sluggish reactions from the Air’s multi-touchscreen gear and leisure system. The Edmunds crew has additionally encountered issues with the Air’s superior security options, together with laggy blind-spot cameras and an adaptive cruise management system that required a reboot to perform correctly. Happily, just like the Mannequin S, the Air is able to receiving over-the-air software program updates, so hopefully a few of these bugs could be fastened sooner or later.
Pricing and pricing
Each these sedans function within the stratosphere of the EV pricing spectrum. Though the Lucid Air nominally begins round $87,400, that mannequin is not obtainable but, so it is too simple to get into six-figure territory. For instance, the Dream Version prices $170,500. In the meantime, the Tesla Mannequin S now begins at round $105,000 and can set you again greater than $137,000 for the ultra-high-performance plaid trim.
Each automobiles have points with construct high quality, so you possibly can count on a minimum of a number of flaws in both sedan. On the guarantee entrance, each the Tesla and Lucid supply 4 years/50,000-miles of primary protection, however Tesla’s powertrain guarantee is barely higher at eight years/150,000 miles for the powertrain and battery. Nevertheless, Lucid does supply three years of free quick charging at Electrify America stations. Each automobiles will put a critical dent in your checking account, however the Mannequin S Plaid is cheaper and gives a degree of acceleration that few automobiles on this planet can obtain, making it a relative cut price.
Winner: Mannequin S
EDMUNDS SAYS: The Lucid Air is an admirable first effort from a brand new automaker, thanks largely to its Tesla-beating vary, otherworldly acceleration, and head-turning exterior design. For now, the Mannequin S holds a slight lead general, but when the Lucid can work by way of its early points, it may effectively finish Tesla’s reign.
This story was supplied to The Related Press by the automotive web site Edmunds. Alex Nishimoto contributes at Edmonds.
Copyright 2022 The Related Press. All rights reserved. This materials will not be printed, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed with out permission.